Where Political Parties Stand on the Regulation of Religion

A conversation between Pastor Mark Penrith (Benoni Baptist Church) and Leisl Pretorius (Head of Legal, Freedom of Religion South Africa).

Introduction

Mark: Hi, my name is Mark Penrith. I am the pastor of Benoni Baptist Church, and this morning I’m joined by Leisl Pretorius, the Head of Legal for Freedom of Religion South Africa (FOSA). We’re going to talk about a matter that is really in the news cycle at the moment. Next week are the national municipal elections in South Africa, and FOSA has a leading story in this regard as it relates to political parties, the Commission for the Promotion and Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities (CRL Rights Commission), and the long-running Section 22 debate.

Leisl, it’s really good to chat to you. Thank you so much for joining me today.

Leisl: Thank you, Mark. I look forward to talking about this important topic with you and the viewers.

The Initiative: Asking the Parties

Mark: You’ve just published a comparison of where political parties stand on the regulation of religion. Maybe you can start by telling us a little about this initiative.

Leisl: Certainly. On the 9th of October, we wrote to every party represented in the National Assembly. They all received exactly the same letter. We asked each for a written position suitable for publication on the CRL Rights Commission’s Section 22 process, and we also enclosed a short schedule of questions.

Seven parties have responded in writing: the ACDP, ActionSA, ATM, BOSA, DA, Freedom Front Plus and UDM. The ANC did not respond, but it issued a media statement on the 13th of October, and we have taken that statement into account in our article and comparison.

The EFF, the IFP, the MK Party and the UAT have told us that they still intend to respond, and we will add their positions once we receive them. As of the 26th of October, we have not yet heard from Al Jama-ah, GOOD, the NCC, the Patriotic Alliance, the PAC or Rise Mzansi. We simply record that fact; we draw no conclusion or inference from it, and we would welcome these parties’ responses in due course.

Mark: That’s a great start, and this really is in the news cycle at the moment. I imagine most people saw the ANC’s response.

Why Ask So Close to the Elections?

Mark: Before we get to who said what, why are you asking this question so close to the elections? The municipal elections are on the 4th of November, so they’re right around the corner.

Leisl: We believe that any election is an important moment for voters to stop and ask the political parties they are considering where they actually stand on issues that matter to them. The Section 22 process also raises very serious questions about the relationship between the state and religion in South Africa. That is of interest to any person of faith, and to anyone interested in democracy and fundamental freedoms. Religious freedom is a key democratic right as well.

These parties sit in the National Assembly. They are the parties that consider legislation as it moves through Parliament, so their stances will affect our lives long after the election is over. We wanted to hear where they stand in their own words and in writing, so that voters can read, consider and weigh the answers for themselves. We’re not telling anybody how to vote. We simply asked the parties, and we’re putting the answers out there.

It’s worth stressing that what we have on our website is a snapshot of the parties’ positions as of the 26th of October. If further responses or clarifications come in, we will update our article accordingly.

What Was Asked: Defining the Terms

Mark: That’s helpful. One of the things I love about talking to Freedom of Religion South Africa is that, being lawyers, you bring pointed debate and conversation to the public domain. Can you give us very clear terms of what was asked of the political parties, perhaps even with definitions?

Leisl: Certainly. The central question was a very simple one: Does your party support state regulation of religion in any form? That includes a statutory council, a registration scheme or a licensing scheme, even one run wholly or partly by representatives from the religious sector.

We defined our terms carefully because the term “self-regulation” is used a lot, and people seem to mean different things by it. By self-regulation, we mean standards that religious communities adopt, own and run themselves. They are set up and funded by the religious communities themselves. By contrast, state regulation is set up, funded or enforced by the state or a statutory body, in other words a body created by an Act of Parliament. You are not free to leave such a body without penalty, or you may be required to belong to it. It is not fully voluntary.

That is where we drew the line. For a system to be truly self-regulation, it must be voluntary: you can decide whether to join or to leave, with no penalty or consequences.

We also asked eleven further questions about what this means in practice, because the crux is often in the details. For example, would a party support legislation later, once a voluntary code exists? Do they see a statutory council led by religious leaders, with sector representatives on it but a statutory council nonetheless, as state regulation or self-regulation?

Mark: That’s good to hear. Eleven questions in addition to the first, so this was a fairly comprehensive submission, and I have no doubt you considered each one carefully.

Is the Difference Just a Technicality?

Mark: Some people might think you’re splitting hairs here with the difference between state regulation and self-regulation. Being a Baptist, this is a matter close to my heart, because the separation of church and state, and persecution by the state, is so entwined with the development of our denominational identity. For the benefit of listeners, can you explain that this isn’t just a technical question?

Leisl: It is a genuine concern, Mark. These technical details have practical consequences, and labels can be misleading. Everybody seems to support self-regulation. We have not found anyone who says they are for state regulation. But a statutory council can call itself self-regulation even if it is staffed by religious leaders. The moment a law puts the state’s backing and power behind that council, it is something else.

So look at the architecture of what is proposed, not just the words. If a law creates a council, gives it powers and funds it, it is not self-regulation. The real test is whether it is truly voluntary to join or to leave, and whether there are legal consequences for those who choose not to join.

It is also important to be clear about what this debate is really about. It is not about whether abuse, fraud and misconduct in religious settings should be dealt with. Of course they should. The question is how we deal with them in a way that doesn’t undermine our fundamental freedoms, and religious freedom specifically.

Existing Laws Are Sufficient

Leisl: On that point, the ACDP, ActionSA, the ATM, the Freedom Front Plus and the UDM all emphasised the importance of using our existing laws and said they are sufficient. BOSA did the same. The DA also said the starting point should be effective enforcement of existing laws, adding that if there are genuine gaps, they must be addressed through carefully tailored and constitutionally justified measures rather than any general system of religious licensing and control.

We were grateful for that feedback, because the parties recognise the important role our existing laws play. FOSA’s position has always been that if our existing laws are applied properly, they can deal with every instance of crime. Crime is crime and misconduct is misconduct, regardless of the setting, the person or the organisation involved.

The Constitution and Limits on Rights

Mark: You’ve spoken about law, and I can’t remember whether it was the DA or the UDM that spoke about the Constitution and its appropriate application. Every time you and I, or you and Michael, have spoken about this, we’ve spoken about the Constitution. Can you tell me how it relates to this conversation?

Leisl: Of course. The Constitution protects religious freedom and the right of people to form and maintain religious associations. Our rights in the Bill of Rights are not absolute, which means they can be limited, and the conditions for limitation are important. Religious institutions remain subject to the ordinary law of the land like everyone else: tax law, criminal law and child protection law apply to us all. The ATM made exactly this point, saying its opposition to religious legislation does not prevent laws of general application from dealing with crime, fraud and abuse.

When a right is limited, it must be done by a law of general application, such as the general criminal law that applies to everyone. The limitation must be reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human rights and freedoms, and it must use the least restrictive means possible.

We asked the parties where they draw the constitutional line, especially regarding future legislation. The DA said it would assess any future legislation against the Constitution. ActionSA said any future proposal would have to show compelling need and constitutional compliance.

Councils Led by Religious Leaders

Leisl: We also asked where parties stand on a council led by religious leaders, because it is often said that if religious leaders sit on the council, it is surely self-regulation. As I’ve said, it depends on the architecture: whether a law backs the council, and whether it is created, empowered or funded by the state.

The ACDP, the ATM, the Freedom Front Plus and the UDM all said that a council created, empowered or funded by law is state regulation, not self-regulation. The DA answered a slightly differently worded question, saying that any body established or empowered by the state to regulate religious institutions is state regulation, even where religious leaders run it. ActionSA said the involvement of religious leaders does not settle the question; it turns on whether the body is voluntary.

The ANC statement likewise refers to self-regulation. It does not specifically speak about statutory bodies and legislation, but we interpret it as a commitment to self-regulation. BOSA did not address the legislation question specifically, but drew a line in its own way. It said the state should not decide what counts as legitimate faith or how people practise it, and that doing so would be an unacceptable expansion of government power. It also urged caution against laws that regulate what may be preached from the pulpit and that begin to limit how people express and practise their faith.

Some parties gave more thorough and detailed responses and others gave shorter statements, but we tried to capture exactly what each was saying. Across the board, those who responded gave a strong sense of what they do not want in practice and where the line lies.

Mark: That’s positive. In general, the parties that responded gave a pro-religious-freedom answer, and it’s telling that certain parties didn’t respond.

Leisl: As I mentioned, some parties have said they still intend to respond, and we welcome their answers. We are not reading anything into the silence. Many parties are very busy during election season, especially the smaller ones. We are very thankful for all the responses we have received, especially those that show an understanding of what religious freedom and true self-regulation mean in practice.

Why Does This Matter for Municipal Elections?

Mark: I’m not trying to throw you a curveball, but I find this fascinating. How does this question relate to municipal elections as opposed to national elections? With national elections, we choose people who sit in Parliament and decide on laws. With municipal elections, we’re choosing councillors who sit on bodies concerned with service delivery. I do appreciate that, because the parties are responding, they see some connection or public interest at this time. Can you draw the line for me?

Leisl: Yes, local government elections are different from provincial and national elections, but the representatives are still from these parties, and we want to know where they stand. An appreciation of what religious freedom means in practice can play out in how you run your local municipality.

There is a White Paper on local government going through the legislative process, and we wrote to the responsible department, the Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (CoGTA). The White Paper recognises different viewpoints. At community meetings, people bring views from their faith, and it’s important that everybody can express their concerns without being silenced, even in those contexts.

It is about creating a culture, from the grassroots up to the provincial and national levels, in which religious freedom is important. If you are an elected official, you are committed to upholding the Constitution and the Bill of Rights fearlessly and protecting all the rights in it, whether at local, provincial or national level. Many people who eventually go to the National Parliament start in local government, and a party is still one party: one policy, one stance, and one strong appreciation for religious freedom across the board.

I must also commend the parties we have been able to talk to over the years. They have been open to listening to us and have supported proposals that protect religious freedom.

Where Is the Section 22 Process Heading?

Mark: From pastors and churchgoers around me, I pick up that there is absolutely no desire to see the state regulate religion. It bodes well for the future that, at least just before elections, the political parties are expressing concerns and are willing to put them in writing. And yet the CRL Rights Commission’s Section 22 process continues. How does the process work? Will it end up before politicians who have already stated their positions? Why has this not fizzled out yet?

Leisl: During the hearings of the Section 22 Committee, it was recorded that the chairperson said there was a legal opinion, apparently posted on the CRL’s website, to the effect that the process can continue until a court says otherwise. They consider the process lawful and the committee lawfully established. That is what we heard from pastors who attended; we attended the Western Cape hearings, not the others. There are those who contest that view, of course.

Consultations remain in four provinces. We have already had KwaZulu-Natal, the Eastern Cape, the Western Cape, Gauteng and Limpopo. Next is Mpumalanga, which leaves the Northern Cape and the North West, and I don’t know in which order the last ones will come. There will be a national summit next year, and then the committee will produce a report for the CRL Rights Commission, which will present it to Parliament.

If the process continues the way they see it, that report will lead to a decision to have some sort of legislative support, because that is what the framework and terms of reference speak about: legislative support for a code of conduct. That is what concerns us, because the moment you have legislation, it is no longer voluntary. It becomes a state mechanism, and you can’t get away from that, even if you want to. That is the nature of the thing.

If there is legislation, it would come through CoGTA, which would have to check it for constitutional compliance. It would then be presented to Parliament and processed through the CoGTA Portfolio Committee. The elected officials who sit on that committee consider these positions, and there are members in the current committee who have spoken strongly against what is being proposed or raised very strong concerns. That is why it is important to raise awareness among these decision-makers, so that if something unconstitutional comes before them, they will head it off at that stage rather than letting it proceed, which would necessitate a constitutional challenge in the Constitutional Court.

FOSA Is Non-Partisan

Mark: As we come to the end, the parties have provided their answers, and you have registered ticks and question marks against the various questions. Where does FOSA stand in all of this? Are you telling people where to vote?

Leisl: No, not at all. FOSA is a non-partisan organisation. We do not recommend or tell anybody how to vote, and our article on our website should not be read that way. We invite people to read it for themselves. Our aim was to put it in the parties’ own words. That is why we sent a copy of the article to the parties and invited feedback, clarifications or corrections. One party did ask us to phrase an opposition position differently, so we are open to feedback.

Viewers can read it and consider for themselves. How each of us votes is our own decision: who we think best represents our concerns and which party will best protect the fundamental rights we value. That is how the article should be read.

Where to Find the Article and How to Participate

Mark: In closing, I encourage anybody with an interest in this topic, or in other topics related to freedom of religion, to go to your website, fosa.org.za. You have articles and videos, and when the time comes to sign petitions, you have links and facilitate that as well. You do a great job on your website and social media channels. Can you point people to this particular article?

Leisl: Yes. On our website, at the top, you will see Resources, and under it, Articles. It will be the latest article, depending on when you view this video.

If any viewers are interested in the Section 22 process and want to raise their views, public participation is our democratic right, and I would also say our responsibility. You can have your say online through the public participation platform, and we have a link for that on our homepage. These are ways you can also stand up for religious freedom.

Mark: Leisl, thank you very much for representing our concerns about religious freedom to the political parties, and for your role in advocacy and in making all of us aware of what’s going on. I really appreciate the work of Freedom of Religion South Africa.

Leisl: Thank you, Mark. It’s a pleasure.

Watch the interview


Discover more from Benoni Baptist Church

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *